In the book, A User-Friendly Guide to the 1888 Message, George R. Knight examines the events surrounding the 1888 session of the General Conference of Seventh-day Adventists in Minneapolis, Minnesota. Fifty-six questions are answered to help the reader understand the history of this still-controversial meeting of church leaders.
Knight begins the book with some historical background, going back to the 1840s, to show some of the reasons for the controversy in the 1880s. Early Seventh-day Adventists were in a world with other Christians, so they tended to emphasize the doctrines that they held that were different from mainstream Christianity. Adventist evangelists learned to be great debaters. One by-product of this debating mentality was a downplaying of the doctrine of righteousness through faith.
Another issue was that many, including General Conference president G.I. Butler and secretary Uriah Smith, held that righteousness was by faith for past sins, but by obedience to God’s law after conversion.
When Alonzo T. Jones and Ellet J. Waggoner, two editors from California, began teaching that righteousness was by faith, not just for past sins, but for the life of the believer, even after conversion, many in the church organization feared that they were downplaying the distinctive doctrines of the importance of obeying God’s law, especially the keeping of the seventh-day of the week holy as the Sabbath. Jones and Waggoner insisted that the distinctive doctrines of the church held more meaning in light of righteousness by grace.
One of the themes that runs through Knight’s book is the strong personalities of Butler and Smith seeing themselves as defenders of the old faith against Jones and Waggoner trying to restore the old doctrine of righteousness by faith as a focal point of Adventist theology. Interestingly, while many groups rightfully point to the contribution that Jones and Waggoner made to Seventh-day Adventism, it was Butler and Smith who remained in the church long-term. Jones and Waggoner both left Seventh-day Adventism, though their paths were different. It seems that if the four men had been willing to honestly study the Bible and listen to each other, at least some of the hard feelings and controversy could have been avoided.
While some groups interested in 1888 seem to put Jones and Waggoner on a spiritual pedestal, Knight demonstrates that, even in 1886-1888, Ellen White did not approve of all that the young preachers were advocating. He proposes that we should examine Ellen White’s statements on their teaching to make sure that we are accepting the parts of the message that were necessary, rather than believing that Ellen White approved of every point that Jones and Waggoner advocated.
Many have debated whether the Seventh-day Adventist Church rejected righteousness by faith in 1888. Knight believes that the answer to that question is no. While acknowledging that many individual administrators, clergy, and lay people did not immediately understand the doctrine clearly, he notes that both Butler and Smith resigned. The next two General Conference presidents, O.A. Olsen and G.A. Irwin, featured Jones and Waggoner as speakers at every General Conference session in the 1890s and gave them numerous other opportunities to preach. The 1890s saw annual meetings for ministers to study the subject at length.
A helpful feature of the book is Knight’s nine “propositions” of implication for the Seventh-day Adventist Church in the early twenty-first century.
Proposition 9 is particularly interesting: “Adventists need to quit bickering with each other over the 1888 message and focus their energies on preaching the messages of the three angels to all the earth” (p. 182). This statement is interesting because Knight several times in the book points out what he believes to be errors in others’ understanding of various aspects of the 1888 message.
Overall, A User-Friendly Guide to the 1888 Message is a very helpful book for anyone wanting to understand the background and some of the historical complexities of the 1888 General Conference session.
A User-Friendly Guide to the 1888 Message by George R. Knight. Berrien Springs, MI: LithoTech, Andrews University. 2006.